Printed fromOxfordChabad.org
ב"ה

Thanksgiving Shabbat Dinner & Debate on the American Elections and impact on the Middle East

Tuesday, 9 December, 2008 - 11:18 am

The Oxford University Chabad Society hosted over 100 guests at a Thanksgiving Shabbat dinner & debate at the Slager Chabad Centre, involving the participation of leading academics and Marshall and Rhodes Scholars at the University of Oxford.

 

The evening commenced with a traditional Thanksgiving turkey dinner with a talk by Rabbi Eli Brackman, director of the Chabad Society, on the horrors of the Mumbai tragedy and the uniqueness of the Chabad couple, Rabbi Gaby and Rivky Holtzberg, who were murdered in this tragic event. He spoke how they represented the patriarch Abraham who gave up personal comfort of home and travelled afar to bring the knowledge and values of Judaism to fellow Jews.

 

This was followed by a debate hosting Professor Ron Bush, Dr Lawrence Goldman and two American graduate students on the subject of "The Impact of the American Elections on the Middle East".

 

The debate was chaired by Daniel Hemel, New College, who is currently a Marshall Scholar and committee member of the Chabad Society. Daniel requested the speakers to predict how in their view the new American administration would, rather than should, impact the Middle East. 

 

Prof. Bush, who is Drue Heinz Professor of American Literature at St. John’s College, said, it's possible to predict the policy of the new administration, since Obama has already picked his key advisors who have already been involved with Israel and the Palestinians and are friends of Israel. Even though Palestinians celebrated the election of Obama, in reality policy will not change against Israel.

 

Dr. Goldman is Fellow of St Peter's College, has published on the political and intellectual history of Britain and the United States in the 19th and 20th centuries and, since 2004, has been Editor of the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. He spoke about the regional Arab threat to Israel's security and Israel's right to defend herself. He didn’t think that peace would be possible unless it is attached to the wider context of Israel's regional security with all its neighbours. He thought Israel will be very low on the agenda of the new administration, after Iraq, Afghanistan, and Iran.

 

A Marshall Scholar, writing a doctoral dissertation in the Department of Politics and International Relations, discussed the recent election of Obama as a moment of cautious optimism for peace in the Middle East. He concluded, in the spirit of the evening's Shabbat/Thanksgiving dinner, with his hope that we would experience a more peaceful world in our lifetime.

 

'The final speaker offered reflections on the principles, policies, and people that  might shape Obama's approach to the Middle East.   He highlighted contradictions between the principles of the campaign and proposed policies, and concluded optimistically that Obama's pragmatism and promise for active engagement with Palestinians and Israelis could create an opportunity for a just peace.

The speeches were followed by a number of questions and contributions from the audience, which included American and Jewish students, academics, and members of the Oxford Jewish community.

 

Dr. Gaston Yalnetzky, Oriel College, commented about the evening, “I think it was very successful and I gathered a lot of very positive opinions from the people who turned up, Jews and non-Jews alike."

Comments on: Thanksgiving Shabbat Dinner & Debate on the American Elections and impact on the Middle East
There are no comments.